$B!!Bh0l$K!"%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$O!":_Mh$N3XLd$N$"$jJ}$X$NLdBjDs5/$r$7$?$H8@$($^$9!#$9$J$o$A!"@lLgJ,Ln$N8&5f$KEv$?$C$F$O!"$=$NBP>]$r6KC<$K69$/8BDj$7!"87L)$JJ}K!O@$NE83+$K>e$K!"BN7O2=!"M}O@2=$r$9$k$H$$$&$N$,>o<1$G$7$?$,!"$`$7$m@lLg$N3XLdJ,Ln$N$o$/AH$_$r1[$($?%@%$%J%_%:%`$NCf$K$3$=!V@8L?!W$r$a$0$kLdBj$,0UL#$r;}$D$H$$$&%f%K!<%/$JH/A[$,%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$N8&5f $B!!(J1969$BG/!"%K%e!<%h!<%/;T9Y30$K@$3&$G$O$8$a$F@_N)$5$l$?%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%98&5f5!4X$H$7$FM-L>$J(J$B%X%$%9%F%#%s%0!&%;%s%?!<(J (The Hastings Center) $B$N%@%K%(%k!&%+%i%O%s=jD9$K$h$k!V3XLd$H$7$F$N%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9!W$H$$$&O@J8$O!"$3$NE@$rL@3N$K;XE&$7$?$b$N$N0l$D$H$7$FCmL\$5$l$^$9(J (The Hastings Center Studies, Institute of Society, Ethics & The Life Sciences, vol. 1, no. 1 $B;2>H(J)$B!#(J
$B!!(J1971$BG/$K$O!"Bg3XIUCV$N:G=i$N%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%98&5f%;%s%?!<$,%o%7%s%H%s(J DC $B$K$"$k(J$B%8%g!<%8%?%&%sBg3X!&%1%M%G%#8&5f=j(J (The Joseph and Rose Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Georgetown University) $B$KH/B-$7!"$=$N%9%?%C%U$rCf?4$H$7$F!V%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9BgI42J;vE5!W(J(Encyclopedia of Bioethics, vol. 1$B!A(J4, ed. by W. T. Reich, Macmillan / Free Press) $B$NJT=8$,$9$9$a$i$l!"(J1978$BG/$K4)9T$5$l$^$7$?!#$3$N;vE5$d!"?tB?$/=PHG$5$l$F$$$k%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$N@lLg=q!"652J=q$r;2>H$9$k$H!"$3$NJ,Ln$N9-HO$5!"%"%W%m!<%A$dJ}K!O@$NB?MM$5$,L\$K$D$-$^$9!#(J
$B!!$D$^$j!"%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$O!"4{$KJF9q$G$O==?tG/$r1[$($kNr;K$r;}$A!"9b9;$dBg3X$J$I$N%+%j%-%e%i%`$N0l$D$H$7$F0l1~DjCe$O$7$F$$$k$b$N$N!"$=$NFbMF<+BN$OI,$:$7$b8GDj$5$l$?$b$N$G$J$/!"$3$NM}O@!"BN7O!"J}K!!"8&5fBP>]$NLL$G(J21$B@$5*$K8~$+$C$F$^$9$^$9K-$+$KBg$-$/7A@.$5$l$D$E$1$F9T$/2DG=@-$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$G$9!#(J
$B!!BhFs$NLdBjDs5/$H$7$F5s$2$i$l$k$N$O!"!V3XLd!W$H!V1?F0!W$H$N7k$S$D$-$G$9!#$3$l$O!"$`$7$m%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$r@8$_=P$94pHW$H$7$F$H$i$($i$l$^$9!#(J
$B!!4{$K$3$NE@$K$D$$$F$O(J1$B7n9f(J$B$G$b>/$7?($l$^$7$?$,!"JF9q$G$N(J1950$BG/Be$+$i(J60$BG/Be$K$+$1$F$N!V?M8"$r]$K$D$$$F$N2ACMH=CG$N4p=`$dNQM}(J ($B%(%F%#%3%9(J) $B$NLdBj$rLd$$D>$7!"8D?M$N%i%$%U!&%9%?%$%k$d8x6&@/:v$^$G$r$b8&5fBP>]$H$9$k$N$,%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$J$N$G$9!#$3$N>l9g!"$"$/$^$G$b$=$N:,$O!"0lHL$N?M$?$A$K$h$kCO0h!& $B!!Bh;0$O!">e$K=R$Y$?$3$H$H?<$/4XO"$7$^$9$,!"!V@lLg2H!&@lLg@-!W$X$NLdBjDs5/$G$9!#$9$J$o$A!";d$?$A0l?M0l?M$,!"<+J,<+?H$K$H$C$F:G$bBg@Z$J!V@8L?!W$N$3$H$K$D$$$F$^$G$b7k6I$O!V@lLg2H!W$KA4$/$f$@$M$F0B?4$7$F$$$?$N$G$O$J$$$+$H$$$&$3$H$X$N?<9o$JH?>J$,!"!V0eNE%7%9%F%`!W$d!V;:6H8x32!W$NHo32N$5$l$k?M!9$b!V5;=Q!W$N%(%-%9%Q!<%H$G$O$"$C$F$b!"!VH=CG!W$,Ho32$NEv;v $B!!!V45$7!"<+J,$?$A$NK>$`2r7h$K8~$+$C$F$N7hDj2aDx$K;22C$7 $B!!8=JNa!"=#K!!";T>rNcEy!9$NN)K!$K$h$j!V?M8"!W$r$BJF9q9qN)1R@88&5f=j(J (NIH : National Institutes of Health)$B!"O"K.@/I\$N(J$BJ]7r!&%R%e!<%^%s!&%5!<%S%9>J(J (U. S. Department of Health and Human Services)$B!"(J$B?)IJ!&LtIJ6I(J (U. S. Food and Drug Administration) $B$J$I$N%,%$%I!&%i%$%s$N@)Dj$H$=$l$K$h$k0Q0w2q@_CV$J$I!#4XO"0Q0w2q$J$I$O$9$Y$F8x3+$5$l;qNA$b<+M3$KF~ $B!!$3$l$i$N%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$NLdBjDs5/$H$=$l$X$NBP1~!"E83+$rF'$^$($?>e$G!";d$?$A$O!"F|K\$N8=l$NCf$G!"4{$K?tB?$/B8:_$7$F$$$k%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$N2j$r%0%m!<%P%k$JJ8L.$K$*$$$FGD0.$7!"F1;~Be;K$N4QE@$+$iL$Mh$K8~$1$F!"F|K\$N%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$rBgC@$K9=A[$7!"E83+$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$H$-$KMh$F$$$k$H;W$$$^$9!#(J

$B!!!!%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$N8&5fJ,Ln!!!!(J

$B!!(J$BJF9q2J3X?66=6(2q(J (AAAS : American Association for the Advancement of Science) $B$ND4::$K$h$k$H!"A4JF$N9bEy650i5!4X$K!V2J3X5;=Q$H2ACM4Q!&NQM}!W$K$D$$$F$N%3!<%9$,Ls(J1, 000$B6a$/$"$j!"$=$N$&$ALs(J3$BJ,$N(J1$B$,%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%94XO"$N652J$H$J$C$F$$$^$9(J (Ethics and Values in Science and Technology, Resource Directory, American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1978)$B!#$3$l$i$N%3!<%9$O$$$:$l$b!"65M\2]Dx$d!"0e3XIt!"8x=01R@83XIt!"M}3XIt!"9)3XIt$J$I$N@lLg2]Dx5Z$SBg3X1!$NE/3X!&NQM}3X$J$I$NI,=$!"$^$?$OA*Br$H$J$C$F$$$^$9!#(J
$B!!$3$l$i$N%3!<%9$O$[$H$s$I$N>l9g!"@lLg$r0[$K$9$kJ#?t$N65;U(J ($BNc$($P0e3X!&K!3X!&?@3X$J$I(J) $B$N%F%#!<%`!&%F%#!<%A%s%0J}<0$K$h$j!"K-IY$J65:`(J ($B%S%G%*!&%9%i%$%I!&1G2h!&H=Nc$d@/I\4)9TJ*!&86E5$N%3%T!<$J$I(J) $B$rMQ$$$F$J$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$3$N%+%j%-%e%i%`$NFbMF$rI.

$B!!!!%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$N%Q%i%@%$%`!!!!(J

$B!!$J$s2s$b7+$jJV$7$F=R$Y$^$7$?$h$&$K!"%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$OB?MM$JN)>l$H;k:B$+$i!"9M;!!"9=A[!"GD0.$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$=$l$i$O $B!!)!!V@8J*3X5Z$S0e3X!W$KE,MQ$5$l$k1~MQNQM}3X$N0lJ,Ln(J (T. Beauchamp, L. Walters $B$J$I(J)
$B!!)"!V@8J*2J3X!W$rCf?4$K$7$?L$Mh$N$?$a$NE/3X(J (V. R. Potter $B$J$I(J)
$B!!)#!VF;FA?@3X!W$N0lE83+$H$7$F$N@8L?$H0e$NNQM}(J (R. McCormick $B$J$I(J)
$B!!)$!VNW>2NQM}3X!W$H$7$F!"$`$7$m0e3X$KAH$_F~$l$k(J (M. Siegler $B$J$I(J)
$B!!$J$I$KJ,$1$i$l$^$9!#(J
$B!!(J1980$BG/$N(J12$B7n$K!"%a%-%7%3!&%7%F%#$G!"!V0e$NNQM}$H0e3X650i!W$N9q:]2q5D$,3+:E$5$l!"I.7$+$l;22C$7$^$7$?(J$B$,!"$=$N@^$K$b%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$NFbMF$H$3$NM}2r$r$a$0$C$FBg$$$KO@5D$,$J$5$l$^$7$?(J (Medical Ethics and Medical Education, ed. by Z. Bankawski, CIOMS-Geneva $B;2>H(J)$B!#$3$N2q5D$NCIOMS ($B9q:]0e2J3X5!9=6(5D2q(J$B!'(J Council for International Organizations of Medical Sciences) $B$O(J WHO $B$H6(NO$7$F!"9q:]E*$J%9%1!<%k$G%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$NLdBj$K $B!!$3$N$h$&$J!"9q:]E*$J!"$^$?2$JF=t9q$G$NF08~$rF'$^$($D$D!":#8eF|K\$G1?F0$H$7$F!"$^$?3XLd$H$7$F$N%P%$%*%(%7%C%/%9$rL$Mh$K8~$+$C$FBg$-$/E83+$7$F$$$/$?$a$N6&DL9`$H$b8@$&$Y$-!V%Q%i%@%$%`!W$r!"I.

($B$D$E$/(J)